Alex: To me it is not fair to sell access 60 + million (+ 40 million duplicates?) profiles and after starting use the customer will realize that maybe 40 million out of the 60 - million are kept in a 'private' sector of Geni.
IMO all these private profiles breaks the foundation (sold) idea of Geni and the World Tree. With all the "private" profiles, that are sold as a part of the tree the geni Pro-users can access until they realize that Geni is as any genealogy sight sold, It takes about a week or to to put in your own family and then the real work start. And then, after paying one realize:
There are very few working on the World Tree.
There are lots of users just keeping there own family and claim every profile of theirs as private family.
They are doing nothing but holding on to their private idea and privacy. (Why don't they keep their private tree on paper at home??!)
Since the paying guest access was claimed by Geni, as all other genealogy sights, there are less growing of the world Tree I think. Many users disliked of course the normal business idea. I'm not sure of all the details Lois always tell about all the dangers all the family of hers are at, if keeping the Geni Idea alive. Because that's the very idea that gives Geni new customers, while all the private profiles chase the customers away.
The power over "family" kills many very good project ideas and keep many akward discssions alive. Akward in the sence one can get answers "Don't you understand .... have feelings .... dont want to tell ... bla, bla, bla..." Of course it's understandable with all the kind of feelings we all have! But if they are hard to handle why not try to be open and fair in a social context and realize that it's not uncommon, it's not fair, it's not correct from another view. E.g. open and honest genealogy.
I belive many Zoombies are there just to keep profiles private as alive. Or something in that way.
I have contacted persons who have left since the Big Geni Change and their answers are almost always the same: The Geni product sold is like a car with a painted steeringwheel and only an illussion of the wheels.
As retired economist I would like to propose: Raise the price twice or more to all the Geni-users who dont like the idea of the World Tree and instead just keep their profiles on Geni as on a private computer. Or put a price on each private, passed away profile above the ordinary Pro-user price. Let's say 1 USD each. Just to messure the willingness to protect the strenght in needs of integracy, "power" or what so ever.
All living and all young protected by Geni, does not need protection by Geni-users. Then Geni-Team every day can go in and easliy "kill" profiles in the 120:d birthday and open the profile that might have a lot bigger family than the one-user would like us to belive.