Terri
I think you're misunderstanding the curator program and scope.
There is NO INTENT to lock family from access to their profiles at all!
The idea is that one single well defined Master Profile will represent every historical figure. To that end, curators are currently:
- merging together duplicates through the *usual* collaborative merge process
- merging together duplicates from abandoned accounts that have been clogging up the database and *preventing* the usual collab / merge process from working correctly
For instance, I am currently merging together 25 copies of "Elder" William Brewster. Every manager on the Profile ***retains*** their edit rights.
"Locking" profiles has so far only been a temporary fix when a historical figure is particularly confused and there are a lot of incorrect, confusing merges that keep coming, mostly a result of lousy GEDCOM copies. Royalty is particularly a victim of this, not the kind of quality, ancestral, well documented and researched profile you're talking about with Mareen Du Val.
And for the record, I have not locked *any* profiles I curate. I see no need to, for one thing: and for another, they are not finalized Profiles as yet: that is, validated by the managers as "this is it, there is no more that we can add to the Profile."
The ultimate goal and flow envisioned is for the group of curators -- and there will be many more than the current team, we're just doing it in waves -- to "manage" additions to the data. In other words, "lock" is envisioned as: this Profile data will only be changed by validated and documented information submitted for review.
If descendants agree that there is no proof of Mareen Du Val's parentage, the way I would see the MP reflecting that is this:
- the Master Profile has all parents broken off
- If necessary, "placeholder" profiles should be created such as "Mareen Du Val's Unknown Mother" and Mareen Du Val's Unknown Father." This will prevent him from being continuously adopted (as mentioned, often by GEDCOM uploads).
- A "curator note" will be floated above the MP to warn about lack of known parentage; this is useful in the merge carousel in particular.
- Arguments for various parents are detailed and sourced within the "overview" tab and a pointer to this discussion, perhaps, if someone has different data
- The MP is not locked because the MP could be enriched
Hope this idea works for everyone. It's the same way I am handling similar issues with the "Mayflower" Passengers.