Aubrée Rozel de Montfort-sur-Risle - What Proves this Person-Profile Linkage to Spouse and Children?

Started by Private User on yesterday
Problem with this page?

Participants:

  • Private User
    Geni Pro
  • Private User
    Geni Pro

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 4 posts

Be aware that this discussion is meant to engender reasonable thought. To date, there is no bona fide source that supports this person-profile.

The curator, Hatte Rubenstein Blejer , has shut down everything – overview, media, data, etc. – which is an odd tactic for an unsourced person-profile with presumed connected relations.

PROBLEMATIC ITEMS
ISSUE 1: Even if Thurstan='ss wife's were known, she would not be about 17 years older than the presumptive husband.
ISSUE 2: The mother of Thurstan's children was not about the age 47 50, and 53 when she gave birth to them.

It looks like someone invented her and attached her to this lord of Bri[c]quebec (correct spelling) whose wife's name is actually unknown, on findagrave and various vanity family genealogy pages; and then it somehow infiltrated Geni's tree.

It is quite odd how she is so securely locked down with unproven information, although not the first time I've found such circumstances.

Examining the Revisions list, it looks like the curators had it right up until 2014 when "the Geni Team" brought in the sketchy birth name, etc.

From that point on it just looks like one or more curators simply automatically(?) reinforced that "Geni Team" change, which was made obviously without supporting documentation.

It looks like George J. Homs gave her the first name, Aubrée, for whatever reason.

Showing all 4 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion