![](http://assets12.geni.com/images/external/twitter_bird_small.gif?1640025624)
![](http://assets13.geni.com/images/facebook_white_small_short.gif?1640025624)
Several things. These are direct ancestors for me but all the dots don't connect on Geni at this point, so I was going to work on that and noticed a few things:
1) These are duplicates I'm unable to merge:
2) The last name is Robins / Robbins. It's well-documented on https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Robins-56 and other sites
3) The name Clarke is NOT part of her father Obedience's name or that of this Margaret's name other than the fact that she was married to a Clarke before she married William Waters. So her father's name was not Obedience Clarke Robins, as one tree shows, and her correct name would be Margaret (Robins) Clarke / Waters.
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Robins-56 - and according to the info on Wiki, her 2nd husband William Waters was her step-brother.
Margaret (Robins) Waters' Find-a-Grave page doesn't mention a first marriage to the Clarke husband. Only her Wiki page mentions him and says that is 'tradition', that there is no documentation.
One tree has her mother as Margaret Parker whereas most sites state her maiden name was unknown. If someone has sources for the maiden name Parker, please share that info her About section.
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Unknown-415660
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/134590592/margaret-waters
I'm not a manager on any of the three profiles for her and am unable to merge the two listed, so I'm hoping someone can fix the names, add the notes, and do the merges and then I continue working on down from her daughter Susannah (Waters) Terrell that my branch is from to get my line connected.
Thanks in advance for any assistance.
Private User - can you take a peek to make sure I merged correctly ? Debbie, Maven is an expert in this area. She highly recommends The Mikes Files as resource, here is their Obedience Robins tree.
http://espl-genealogy.org/milesfiles/site/p254.htm#i25357
Actually - Maven discredited the wikitree listings in this March 2021 discussion.
https://www.geni.com/discussions/227629?msg=1458083
Important points:
I’m cleaning up accordingly unless more evidence can be presented.
I know the answer.
We don’t know who her parents are and they are and we are not likely to know without more England research into Terrell family connections and a great deal of luck.
She doesn’t belong to the Edward Waters tree. I reed on another discussion you were on in March that she’s not likely to have originated in a London slum. Be that as it may, the London family seems unlikely.