Elizabeth Collier (Cresap) - Death Location for Elizabeth (Cresap) Collier

Started by Joseph E Crouch on Tuesday, May 19, 2020
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 4 posts
5/19/2020 at 12:03 PM

The Isaac Collier who married Elizabeth Cresap did not migrate to Shelby Co., KY.

Tax records in Shelby Co., KY from 1802 to 1815 consistently show this Isaac Collier's son Michael Collier in Shelby Co., KY. with significantly more assets than the Isaac Collier listed adjacent to him. That Isaac Collier starts out being listed as over 21, but without any assets. Michael Collier's son Isaac Collier was born in 1780, so the Isaac Collier listed has to be the grandson of the Isaac and Elizabeth (Cresap) Collier in this profile.

As only Michael Collier (married Elizabeth Parker) who migrated to Shelby Co., KY and his sons appear in the Shelby Co., KY. tax lists, did Elizabeth (Cresap) Collier really die in Shelby Co., KY. ?

The most that can be proved is that Isaac and Elizabeth (Cresap) Collier's last proven location was in that portion of Frederick County, MD that became Washington County, MD. in 1776 and in 1789 became Allegany Co., MD.

5/19/2020 at 12:16 PM

I suspect given the confusion among Collier descendants as to their lineage, several Collier's had Michael Collier marrying his mother in lieu of Elizabeth Parker 1766-aft 1826, daughter of Nathaniel Parker 1724-1811 and Elizabeth Scott. Elizabeth (Parker) Collier died aft 1826, thus the 1826 death date.

Thus the multiple DAR submissions for Michael Collier having married Elizabeth Cresap, and the DAR now only recognizing Isaac Collier as the husband of Elizabeth Cresap.

This is reinforced by:Jonathan Jacobs 1826 book A Biographical Sketch of the life of the late Captain Michael Cresap wherein he stated:

""Elizabeth, the youngest daughter of Colonel Thomas Cresap, was married to a Mr. Isaac Collier, from Pennsylvania, who was a rather dissipated character. They are both dead, but left several children, who reside in the States of Kentucky, Ohio and Alabama, and all of them are wealthy and respectable."

Jonathan Jacobs said "They are both dead" BUT left several children who reside in the States of KY., OH & AL He does not state Isaac & ELizabeth Cresap Collier migrated, just their children.

5/20/2020 at 10:44 AM

Hello Joseph E Crouch, I am not directly related to this family. Would you like for me to copy your comments / information the Elizabeth's profile page? They would be helpful for other descendants later on. Thank you so much.

5/20/2020 at 10:56 AM

Feel free to do so. I've already posted similar verbiage to his & Elizabeth Cresap's profiles on FamlySearch, WikiTree, and WeRelate.

This morning I found the mis-transcribed 1810 Shelby Co., KY. census record for the Isaac Collier in early Shelby Co., KY. He had 3 sons under the age of 10 and 1 daughter under the age of 10 which matches the known children for Isaac & Jincy (Willis) Collier, son of Michael Collier and Elizabeth Parker.

I've also edited FamilySearch, Wikitree and WeRelate profiles tand added this statement:

Isaac and Elizabeth (Cresap) Collier's last proven location was in that portion of Frederick County, MD that became Washington County, MD. in 1776 and in 1789 became Allegany Co., MD. Oldtown (aka Cresaptown) is now located in Allegany CO., PM.

Showing all 4 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion