Kevin Lawrence Hanit,
I've run into some problems with the branch of G8.3 Leah, from Chapter 13, page 650, and need your assistance with sorting out the confusion (which happens to involve a couple of profiles that you curate). This is Leah's profile:
Leah Rokeach-Gelernter, ch#7
According to Ch.13, page 650, her first marriage, after the 1718 death of her father, was to a son of Reb Haim Reb Lazers, and from this marriage, she had a grandson, i.e. G10 Abraham Lazarus: R' Abraham Lazarus (Biha) Banet (Ashkenazi) I think that perhaps there was a numbering issue, and that Abraham should actually have been listed as a son, and not a grandson of Leah, because of the reference that is given in the entry for G10 Abraham Lazarus, which refers us to Volume 1, page 194, for the descendants of his father-in-law, i.e. Rabbi Avraham Aberl (Eberl) Banet Following this branch, to page 200, is the entry for his daughter G9.3 Fradel Jaffe Banet Ashkenazi who was married to R' Abraham Lazarus (Biha) Banet (Ashkenazi)?through=6000000007051588633. In this passage, it says that Abraham's grandfather was Reb Haim Reb Lazers, and it also says that Abraham's mother was Leah, daughter of the Chacham Zvi.
Further, there are problems with the dates on the Geni profile for G10 Abraham Lazarus, which indicate that he was born in 1712 and died in 1758. First off, since Leah was not even married to her first husband until at least 1718, it isn't possible for her to have had a son (let alone a grandson) who was born in 1712. Also, according to UC, Fradel and Abraham had 2 daughters born in 1760 and 1763, and a son (R. Isaiah Banet), who was born in 1768/9. Clearly, if this is the case, he could not have died in 1758. Perhaps he has been confused with his father-in-law, Avraham Aberl Banet, who may have died in 1758??
Currently, the profile for G10 Abraham Lazarus (aka Abraham Bihaly or Bia, i.e. the Abraham who was married to Fradel, daughter of Abraham Aberl Banet), does not have him connected to Leah, as his mother. In fact, it does not have him connected to any mother at all. I also do not see him connected to any Reb Haim Reb Lazers as a grandfather. I see that he is currently listed as being a son of R' Judah Ashkenazi whose father was Nathan (Moshe) Ashkenazi (s#8) Rav in Brodi Yeshiva which contradicts the information found in U.C. The book indicates (in Ch 2, page 200, entry G9.3) that Abraham Lazarus's grandfather was the Katzin (officer) Reb Haim Reb Lazer's, mechuten to R. Zvi Hirsch Ashkenazi, the Chacham Zvi, and that Abraham's mother was Leah, daughter of the Chacham Zvi. So... as far as I can tell, there is no indication that Abraham Lazarus himself was an Ashkenazi, only that his grandfather, Reb Haim Reb Lazers has an in-law to the Chacham Zvi. Is it possible that there was a bad merge at some point, where Abraham Lazarus got confused with a different Abraham, who was an Ashkenazi?
According to U.C., Leah was married 4 times, but in the relationship section of her profile, the marriages are ordered with only marriage #2 and marriage #3 being present. So, it seems that she is not currently connected to her 1st husband, i.e. the one who was the son of Reb Haim Reb Lazers, and presumably the father of G10 Abraham Lazarus.
Let me know how you would like to handle this, and what modifications you think should be made to correct these problems.
Thanks,
Claudia
Problem with this page?
Private UserGeni member
Geni Pro
Geni Pro
Geni member