Adelaid or Athalia - Generational mismerge

Sharon Doubell C

6/8/2018 at 11:55 PM

From what I can see, this profile has been mismerged to a generation above where it should be
Terry Jackson (Switzer)'s Curator note puts her as Pepin's granddaughter
"Daughter of ? Unknown Daughter of Pepin
Wife of Billung No Surname
Mother of Oda"

At present she's positioned as a duplicate of his daughter by that name.
As I'm wanting to RL Pépin, king of Italy - I'm cutting his set of this profile's parents (Presently Daughter of "Pépin" Carloman, King of Italy; Pepijn van Italië; Bertha of Toulouse and Gundrade der Franken)

Terry - please come and check that this profile then defaults to the parents you intended it to have.

Sharon Doubell C

6/8/2018 at 11:57 PM

Jason Scott Wills I see you're curating.

Terry Jackson (Switzer) C

6/9/2018 at 4:58 PM

Sharon Doubell, it seems to me that Ben M Angel's summary in the about me matches what Medlands Says about this profile - it is very unclear and obviously there is uncertainty about her - it seems uncertain whether she was illegt. or not, whether she was full sibing or half sibling of Bernard, who her mother was etc. etc.

I am usually very careful when doing my curator notes to record relationships as they should be as I know that this can become lost in merges but I can't see anything to support her being Pepin's grand-daughter from the about me or previous edits. I haven't had time to do much research on this. If you want me to look closer it will have to wait as real life is very busy for me at the moment.

Sharon Doubell C

6/9/2018 at 11:17 PM

I'm going to cut the relationship as do Gundrade der Franken as that appears to arb. I'll leave the rest to you and Jason when you get time.
Thanks for looking.

Linda Wellman

6/10/2018 at 7:34 AM

Guess I'm confused.....if you feel she was the daughter of an unknown daughter of Pepin, why cut her parents entirely, instead of leaving a path?
Thanks

Sharon Doubell C

6/10/2018 at 9:27 AM

Because we don't know who her parents were, and Terry is saying that she's not sure where the 'daughter of an unknown daughter of a Pepin' info came from'.
No info tells us that she's the daughter of Gundrade; and no info from Pepin tells us he has an unknown daughter.

Adelaid or Athalia - Generational mismerge

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion