Osmunda de Whalesborough - Clarifications needs - seems confousing

she can't be the sister of her son, so if they're the same, at least one of the relationships cited is wrong (the one to Sir William de Whalesborough (1210-1279)).

Names and estimated birth dates don't fit either.

why do you think they should be the same?

I don't really - but what do I know? #1 death dates are exactly the same Death: March 8, 1293 which could be viable #2 estimated births dates do fall into the same time frame - one giving more leeway as to be being earlier or later since they are estimated - one has to guess as to what they are based on - not good at guessing games...

I am posing the question - it they are one in the same - this is EXACTLY how i found the information listed - I ASKED for CLARIFICATION - I wanted the user names/curators attached to the profiles to know that there was a possible problem the esxits

besides this being classified as the Medieval era and basically a "Hands off" area for us normal GENI users.

I am climbing my grandson-in-law tree and inputting into my off line files - it is also when I get there probably 95% of my ancestry also via my mom & dad his is totally unconnected to mine right now and affording me a "recovery" of the European lines I had to dump past my immigrant ancestors a couple of years ago because of a GENI GEDCOM down load - I severed all but a couple of lines backwards after the 1st immigrant grandparent to salvage the the file i had been working on for 40+ years.

I seem to have been confused about which two profiles you were talking about.

Are you talking about these two?

Cecilia Trevarthian
Cecilia Trevarthian

From the headline and the initial mail, I thought you were talking about Osmunda and Cecilia, which I couldn't understand.

Yes, those two look very similar (and very undocumented).

Explicitly tagging Will Chapman (Vol. Curator) who entered one of those.

Thank you - it also deals with her possible unnamed spouse "Sir" and then the 2 william's Sir William de Whalesborough (1210-1279) and William de Whalesborough(1240-) and if i am reading and deducing right the conflicts came in when William de Whalesborough(1240-) was added ... the whole area needs to be looked at and clarifedbetter