Sarah Chase - Who are the parents of Sarah Chase?

Sarah Hathaway is the daughter of Benjamin Case and Philippa Sherman Case.

According to the MyHeritage trees, the Sarah born in Freetown married Daniel Grinnell so I really do believe they are different people.

And there was already a Sarah Chase Grinnell, married to Daniel Grinnell, on Geni so I have merged them.

Daniel Grinnell, of Little Compton

It looks like Benjamin Chase, married to Philippa Sherman, had a daughter, Sarah, whose husband was Daniel Grinnell, witness:

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Chase-181 which cites Benjamin's will:

Dated 6 Sep 1730.[6]

to sons Benjamin and Walter
to grandson Benjamin Grinnell
to dau Bethiah Dunham
to dau Philippe Hathaway
to son-in-law Jacob Hathaway
to granddaughter Sarah, wife of Isaac Hathaway
to grandchild Daniel Grinnell

Sarah Hathaway was married to Abraham Hathaway (Abraham, John, Nicholas).

I do not believe that she was ALSO married to Nathaniel Talbot. Please join the discussion if you can find more information about when she died and whether she married a second time.

She was definitely NOT the mother of Abial Talbot who married her son Abel Hathaway supposely. That would have made them half-siblings who could not marry and she would have had to be married to Nathaniel Talbot first. I believe his wife, Sarah, was of unknown parentage. I have not found reliable sources although there are books about the Hathaways (Nicholas Hathaway is the first of this line) and Talbots.

Sarah Grinnell, wife of Daniel, WAS the daughter of Benjamin Chase and Philippa Sheran.

It's Sarah Hathaway, wife of Abraham, who is NOT their daughter.

See also: https://www.geni.com/discussions/176529

To summarize:

There were two Sarah Chase profiles both originally attached to Benjamin Chase and Phillipa Sherman Chase. The correct daughter is the Sarah Chase married to Daniel Grinnell. The other Sarah Chase seems to be the daughter of a William Chase and was married to Abraham Hathaway.

There are remaining questions:

Is Sarah Chase Grinnell married to the correct Daniel Grinnell in the tree now? Erica Howton I think you curate Daniel Grinnell and it looks like he may have had only one wife.

Who is the mother of Abial Talbot married to Abel Hathaway? I have changed the mother to an unknown Sarah which makes more sense than that Abel Hathaway married his half-sister. Or that Sarah Chase Hathaway wife of Abraham was first married to Nathaniel Talbot.

Was Sarah Chase Hathaway married a second time, to Nathaniel Talbot, after the death of her husband Abraham Hathaway?

So Hatte, if you believe Daniel only had one wife, then is Lydia not his wife. They married in 1683, as per this record. One child Benjamin was born in 1670 to whom?
A little confusing. This is my daughter in law's family (I hope).
Arlene White (Australia)

Excellent question, I see the problem since both wives lived long lives.

I'll have to research this.

If it helps any, Sarah Grinnell was married to a different Daniel Grinnell (son the 2nd Matthew)

See Torrey’s New England Marriages

https://www.geni.com/documents/view?doc_id=6000000077940664848&

Here is the will of Benjamin Chase (d 1730)

https://www.geni.com/documents/view?doc_id=6000000077943339066&

His daughter Sarah was already dead. He names his Grinnell grandsons. Their father Daniel was not the one who married Lydia Pabodie. I’ll try & find more on him such as did he remarry ...

Thank you Erica Howton!

I woke up this morning and started to work on the mystery of Sarah Chase's husband and you had solved it in the middle of the night :)

Thank you for the overview update on Sarah, nicely described.

This Daniel Grinnell’s sister married a Carpenter, which means a mention in Carpenter Cousins

http://carpentercousins.com/Joseph3_Rehoboth&Swansea.pdf

Genealogist Eugene Cole Zubrinsky just completes his biannual
Update for them, in fact (April 8).

And has a new article out on the Sutton’s

https://www.americanancestors.org/browse/publications/the-register/...

This is an old post and I am not sure if you figured this out based upon the conversations I just read but here is the information I have. My son is a double Hathaway on both side (his father's side and my side. Captain Abraham Hathaway is my son's 7th and 8th grandfather depending on who's side you are looking at. This is the information for Sarah Hathaway on both trees.

Her Father was: Daniel Miller Chase
Grandfather: Aquila Chase
there are 2 Aquila Chases and the other one's family line died in England this one is related to Gerald Ford.

When Sarah Chase was born in 1690 in Berkley, Massachusetts, her father, Daniel, was 29. She married Captain Abraham Hathaway on January 28, 1709, in Dighton, Massachusetts. They had ten children in 18 years. She died on February 9, 1754, in Morristown, New Jersey, at the age of 64.

Facts
1690
(AGE)
Select fact
Birth
1690 • Berkley, Bristol, Massachusetts, United States
1 source
1706
Age 16
Death of father Daniel Miller Chase(1661–1706)
1706 • Newbury, Essex, Massachusetts,
1708
Age 18
Birth of son Philip Hathaway(1708–)
1708
1708
Age 18
Birth of son Abel Hathaway(1708–1761)
1708 • Taunton, Bristol, Massachusetts, United States
1709
Age 19
Select fact
Marriage
28 January 1709 • Dighton, Bristol, Massachusetts, United States
Captain Abraham Hathaway
(1685–1754)

1709
Age 19
Birth of son Abraham Hathaway(1709–1787)
28 January 1709 • Dighton, Bristol, Massachusetts, United States
1712
Age 22
Birth of daughter Susanna Hathaway(1712–1783)
16 Jan 1712 • Dighton, Bristol, Massachusetts, United States
Year 1714
Age 24
Birth of son Jonathan Hathaway(1714–1814)
16 Oct 1714 • Berkley, Bristol, Massachusetts, United States
1716
26
Birth of son Simeon Hathaway(1716–1754)
16 Sep 1716 • Dighton, Bristol, Massachusetts, United States
1718
28
Birth of daughter Sarah Hathaway(1718–)
13 Sep 1718 • Dighton, Bristol, Massachusetts, United States
1720
30
Birth of son Shadrach Hathaway(1720–1756)
1720 • Dighton, Bristol, Massachusetts, United States
1723
33
Birth of son Benjamin Hathaway(1723–)
10 Mar 1723 • Berkley, Bristol, Massachusetts, United States
1726
36
Birth of daughter Abigail Hathaway(1726–)
7 OCT 1726 • Dighton, Bristol Co., Mass.
1754
64
Death of husband Captain Abraham Hathaway(1685–1754)
9 Feb 1754 • Morristown, Morris, New Jersey, United States
1754
Age 64
Death
9 February 1754 • Morristown, Morris, New Jersey, United States

Abial Bial Talbot from tree Lewis Family Tree
Record information.
Birth 1 Dec 1707 Taunton, Bristol, Massachusetts, USA
Death 1740 Bristol, Massachusetts, USA
Record information.
Father Nathaniel Talbot (1681-1734)
Record information.
Mother Sarah Goodwin (1687-1761)

Who is the Sarah Chase she is referring to? or is she confused with Sarah Goodwin the wife of Nathaniel Talbot? The profile you linked I believe to be incorrect. This is actually Kyle's mother we started this project when he was 10 he is not almost 21. He is a double Hathaway on both sides. Captain Abraham Hathaway is his 7th and 8th grandfather so Sarah appears twice for him. Once on his father's side and once on my side. He is also a direct descendent of Myles Standish Captain of the Mayflower. Fortunately due to that a lot of his trees are all ready very researched an vetted.