Susan Jennifer Cooper thanks for the info. I appreciate it :) So the culprit was Martin Van Buren. Funny that I'm related to him as well.
Martin Van Buren, 8th President of the USA is your 13th cousin five times removed.
As far as infamous or "notorious" cousins go, I have a few of them as well, LOL.
Folks like Lizzy Bordon (dang it, I can't get that song out of my head now), Billy the kid and Jesse James ( I like both of those actually).
But like my cousin Barbara Jean TWEDT I'm also related to Charlie Manson. Nothing I can do about it but I'm not about to rewrite history just to make myself "feel better".
As cousin Erica "the Disconnectrix" Howton, has explained in great detail, it's just a matter of getting his lineage properly sourced and vetted. Better to make sure all the connections are correct than just take an overly aggressive genealogist's word who possibly jumped to some conclusions.