Pierre Godin dit Châtillon - Pierre Godin dit Châtillon's Death: c1685? or 1700?

For this profile:

Pierre Godin dit Châtillon

I just cannot find as of yet a definitive source about his place and date of death. There are two different hypotheses:

--- Hypothesis A ---

He died in Acadia, before the 1686 census. His wife, Jeanne Rousselière, remarried in 1687. There is no direct record (as far as I know) of Pierre's death supporting this hypothesis.

These sources seem to indirectly support this hypothesis:

https://www.geni.com/documents/view?doc_id=6000000052051697914

https://www.geni.com/documents/view?doc_id=6000000052057293917

http://www1.gnb.ca/0007/Culture/Heritage/VMC/tell_story02.asp?year=...

--- Hypothesis B ---

Pierre returned in Québec before 1686 by himself, perhaps in secret. He is believed death by his family, thus his wife can remarry. Then he dies in 1700. The Church record shows only his name and approximate age of 55. No family mentioned.

This is the Church record:

https://www.geni.com/documents/view?doc_id=6000000052051402121

and Tanguay seems to agree that this is about this profile:

https://www.geni.com/documents/view?doc_id=6000000052051402119

--- Discussion ---

Being born in 1630, he should be 70 in 1700, not 55. This shed some doubts on whether the Church record is really about this Pierre Godin, and not someone else. That someone else (if he exists) would be born in 1645.

However, I cannot find any Pierre Godin (or Gaudin, Cottin) born c1645. I cannot find any other Pierre Godin who would have died in 1700 either.

--- Your Help Please ---

If you have any other sources that may support either hypotheses, please post them with the profile and let me know. For example, I`d really like to see what PRDH and Francogen have on this profile.

morel