Emma de Cornouailles - Incorrect name change?

Started by Terry Jackson (Switzer) on Saturday, September 17, 2016

Emma de Cornouailles's parents were changed to NN de Mortain(?) and NN de Mortain(?) by Jean-Marie MUSSINI.(5 Jul at 5:36 AM)
If the parents of a profile really are not known then I agree that we should mark them as such but in this instance we have cited Medlands who are generally a trusted source who say that she is the daughter of Réginald Dunstanville de Dunstanville, 1st Earl of Cornwall and Beatrice (Mabilia) fitzWilliam. This is also stated very clearly in the Curator note at the top of the profile. These notes are there to guide people not to make errors or changes without first consulting the curator.
I am the curator of this profile and was not consulted.
Emma de Cornouailles, if you, or anybody else, have any reliable sources to suggest that we AND Medlands have it wrong I suggest you come forward with them.
In the meantime I will be reinstating the parents as sources suggest they should be.

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion